Customer Reviews for Superior Automotive & Tire

We love hearing what our customers have to say!

We want you to be completely satisfied with our service, so please let us know how we’re doing.

If you have a review you’d like to share, click the button below and fill out the form below.


Here’s what some of our Buffalo, WY customers are saying about us:

This shop is a life saver! I broke down passing through town and got a tow to their shop. The customer service is the best I've seen. They were quick to find my problem with no run around and treated me like family even giving me and my dogs a ride to my hotel for the night. I'm so grateful for this shop and all they have done for me. I highly recommend superior automotive & tire

Nate Superior Automotive & Tire Customer Review

Gary and the crew at Superior Automotive are the best. They went above and beyond to get us back on the road when we broke down in Buffalo on our cross country RV road trip.

Margaret Wilkerson Google Review

Gary is great!

Kristin Ellis Google Review

Truck died just off the Interstate and called Superior. Gary came out and after determining my truck would not stay running after being jump started, pulled me through Buffalo back to the shop. Offered me a ride back home but a friend picked us up. Friends told me it sounded like the alternator had gone out so I was expecting the worse. Gary called the next day to say it was only the battery and it was ready to go. Thanks Gary and Superior Auto! Another reason to shop locally. Service, friendly, dependable repair and fair in price.

Bill Charles Superior Automotive & Tire Customer Review

Truck was broke down on a Friday afternoon and arrived at Superior Automotive at 3:30. Gary figured out what the problem was and asked one of his employees if they would be willing to work a little bit longer to repair the truck. Cody volunteered and by 6:00 I was back on the road. Great work ethic and very friendly service.

Gary Smith Superior Automotive & Tire Customer Review

Fast friendly service. Squeezed me in in an emergency to get me back on the road.

Hale Redding Facebook Review

Great work on my car. Discount for Veterans

Tom Musgrove Google Review

5 Stars!

Shelby Lopez Google Review

Gary and his service crew are indeed very professional. On our annual travel to Buffalo, WY., Our Jeep tow vehicle developed numerous dashboard lights relating to the braking system. Superior evaluated the situation, corrected the problem in a very timely fashion. Cost for their service was very reasonable.

Bob Guidry Superior Automotive & Tire Customer Review

5 Stars!

Seth Lambert Google Review

Very professional and helpful. Stayed late to help us out. Thanks

Chad Fisher Google Review

5 Stars!

Jen Sewell Google Review

I used to work for Jim and i cant say enough, very nice guy and friendly always had work. For everyone. Smart as well. We had a great team when i worked thier elit jim and i. Did all of the work.

michael dalench Google Review

Gary & Jim are men of absolute integrity. Will do the job, well and will charge you what was quoted. The best place in Buffalo for vehicle repairs or regular maintenance.

Aboo Rawat Google Review

5 Stars!

Mary Peden Google Review

I am very happy with everyone they are always quick to get my vehicle in. They always do a good job and are fair. Thank you Gary and all of your wonderful team!!

Shannon Bradish Google Review

My exhaust had a leak. On my way from bozeman montana to nyc (in Wyoming) the exhaust went fell off and start d to drag on i90. I called right as the superior auto was closing at 5pm. The shop closes at 5pm and i can see any other shop close their doors and head home; but the guys stayed overtime.

Gary was very accommodating. Fixed me up in no time and pricing very reasonable. And i was back on the road to ny. Here we go 28hrs to go!

I recommend Gary and his mechanical service and expertise. Great guys, good work, good customer support. Not overpriced!

Egor Astakhov Google Review

These guys are really great. Very friendly people, so glad I decided to go here based on other reviews when my car started running really loudly while going through the mountains on my cross-country road trip. Turned out it was just a hole in the exhaust pipe that they patched up for me, and I had my car back and good as new just a few hours after I dropped it off. Considering other more dishonest shops might have seen a solo woman in a bind and tried to tell me I needed a whole new exhaust system or something, I really appreciated the simple fix that didn't break my travel budget and got me back on the road. Definitely recommend Gary Spade and the rest of Superior Automotive!

Carrie Hatfield Google Review

SUPERIOR AUTOMOTIVE. August 2015, I'm certain this is now Superior Automotive. However, we were recommended by the staff at Buffalo KOA (see TripAdvisor post of same date). We were experiencing a mechanical issue with our 26' class C motor home and Gary, the owner, accommodated us despite his already busy schedule. I had given him a very thourough briefing on what we were experiencing and of the environmental conditions when the symptoms presentedthemsves. He did a computer diagnosis of the rig, and gave me excellent and sound professional advice to allow me to make an educated decision on how to proceed.

No repair was necessary, and we made it to our vacation destination Gary even provided us with some advice on what to see along the way.

Trustworthy and reliable.

thomas richter Google Review

5 Stars!

A Google User Google Review

We heard scratching noises from the rear right wheel when we drove out of Big Horn National Forest and when we stopped at Buffalo, Wy., we saw a piece of warped metal scratching the disc inside the wheel. As Orientals driving through town with an Ontario licence plate, we were ready to be fleeced. On the recommendation of our hotel's receptionist, we took the car to Jim's. The shop looked quite busy but a mechanic attended to us rather quickly. He took a look at the wheel, crawled under, ripped out the dust shield and told us we were good to go. He also made us drive a short distance to observe the wheel to make sure everything was OK. No charges for us. Everyone in the shop was very courteous and friendly. Our only regret is not asking for the names of the people involved so we can thank them properly. May their good works be rewarded in return!

A Google User Google Review

Oh my goodness, these guys are SO wonderful. Our poor VW camper van busted a belt out in the middle of I-90, 40 miles from the closest shop. We weren't sure if anything else was ruined, smoke and coolant went everywhere, it was just a mess. We were towed in to Jim's at 11:55am on a Saturday, (when they closed at noon) and they totally took care of us, even after closing. No rush, no fuss, nothing but pure friendliness and professionalism. They fixed our belt, tightened everything else, and thoroughly checked out the rest of the van to make sure we could make it all the way home to CA (which it did!). Wyoming doesn't seem to have a lot as far as VW specialists, but these guys took super good care of our Westfalia, and got us back on the road with no problem. I was super pleased with our experience! Thanks guys!!! : D

A Google User Google Review

I can't say enough about these guys. They're unusually down to earth, but they're also really good at what they do. They did the oil change right by allowing all the oil to drain for about 30 minutes. Most quick lube places act like this doesn't matter, but that's just because they're looking to make more money on more cars. The people at Jim's know what they're doing and they take the job seriously. They also noticed that my timing belt was about to break. Hell, it just might be worth the trip to Buffalo to get the job done right.

A Google User Google Review

Add Your Own Review!